Plunge All-In vs Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub
The Plunge All-In costs $7,990 and the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub costs $3,100. This comparison covers the full spec sheets of both, the deciding difference between them, and which buyer each one fits.
This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure
Our verdict
The choice between the Plunge All-In ($7,990) and the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub ($3,100) comes down to built-in chiller; only the Plunge All-In carries a sourced owner rating, so there is no like for like quality verdict. The Plunge All-In includes a built-in chiller, while the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub does not. The Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub saves you $4,890; pay the difference for the Plunge All-In only if that gap buys a spec you will use.
Which one is right for you?
It depends on your situation.
Choose the Plunge All-In if
Plunge All-In: You want a built-in chiller.
Choose the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub if
Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub: You want no built-in chiller. The Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub also costs $4,890 less than the Plunge All-In.
Full specs comparison
| Spec | Plunge All-In | Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $7,990 | $3,100 |
| Built-in Chiller | Yes | No |
| Water Capacity | 125 gal | 420L / 111 gal |
| Dimensions | 66" × 32" × 28" | 55" × 39" × 37" |
| Weight | 280 lbs | · |
| Warranty | 2 years | · |
| Temp Range | 39-104°F | · |
Pros and cons
Plunge All-In
Pros
- Set-and-forget temperature control
- No ice needed ever
- Hot tub functionality included
- Premium build quality
- Excellent customer support
Cons
- High upfront cost
- Requires electrical hookup
- Heavy (280 lbs)
- Higher energy consumption
Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub
Pros
- Distinct charred-pine aesthetic
- Stainless steel interior resists bacteria
- Mid-tier price point
Cons
- No chiller included
- Premium price vs the portable
Plunge All-In vs Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub: common questions
How much more does the Plunge All-In cost than the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub?
The Plunge All-In costs $7,990, which is $4,890 more than the $3,100 Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub. Beyond price, the main spec difference is built-in chiller: the Plunge All-In offers yes, the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub offers no.
Is the Plunge All-In worth it over the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub?
There is no quality winner between the Plunge All-In and the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub on the data we can verify. The Plunge All-In includes a built-in chiller, while the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub does not.
Does the Plunge All-In or the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub include a chiller?
The Plunge All-In offers a built-in chiller; the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub offers no built-in chiller. That is the deciding spec difference between the two.
Which is better for athletes, the Plunge All-In or the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub?
The Plunge All-In is the better fit for athletes; it is the one we tag for that use. The Plunge All-In includes a built-in chiller, while the Canuck Cold Carbonized Pine Cold Tub does not.
Neither of these quite right?
Take our 60-second quiz and we will match you with the best option for your budget, space, and goals.